VARDR Program Review
Missouri

Synthetic data. Practice names are invented. Several practices carry planted billing patterns, and several benign look-alikes are planted to show what the analysis declines to flag. Cases, people and outcomes are invented too.

Program integrity · Medicaid · Missouri

Billing Pattern Watch

Paid claim lines compared with same-specialty peers: codes per visit, units, office-visit levels, modifiers, spend per patient and growth. A flag is a statistical anomaly for analyst review under 42 CFR 455.13–.14. It is not a finding of improper payment, and never a conclusion about intent.

Practices compared
42
2026Q3, against 6 quarters
Priority review
5
two or more independent signals, persistent
Scheduled review
1
one persistent signal
Expected false leads
0.00
among this quarter's flags, by the method's own estimate
Period: 2026Q3, with 6 quarters of history for persistence and growth. The synthetic extract is complete, so no quarter is held back; an agency's extract holds quarters inside a 90-day window.

Where each practice sits against its peers

Choose a measure. Select a mark to open the practice.

Priority reviewScheduled reviewRoutine95% limits99.8% limits
0.0×0.5×1.0×1.5×2.0×2.5×5102050100200500peer rateExpected count at peer rates (volume, log scale)Observed ÷ expectedMotion Physical TherapyClearwater Counseling

Each mark is a practice in the latest quarter. The funnel narrows as volume grows, so a small practice needs a larger ratio to sit outside it. Limits allow for overdispersion (φ = 1.0). The tier reflects every measure, persistence and the false-discovery control, not this chart alone.

Review list

Ordered by tier, then by the number of independent signal families, then by paid amount. Correlated measures count once per family.

Include routine practices
PracticeTierSignalsLeading observationPaid in window
Caring Hands Home Care
In-home personal care · Jackson County
Priority review
SpendCodingBilled time
Paid per patient is 4.16× the peer median ($9,674 vs $2,324).$1,037,160
Motion Physical Therapy
Physical therapy · Jackson County
Priority review
CodingSpendBilled time
Bills 2.39× the codes per visit of peers in the same specialty.$424,015
Clearwater Counseling
Mental health counseling · Jackson County
Priority review
CodingVisitsSpend
Bills 1.72× the codes per visit of peers in the same specialty.$236,432
New Path Behavioral
Mental health counseling · Greene County
Priority review
VisitsSpendGrowth
Sees each patient 2.96× as often as peers in the same specialty.$180,570
Riverbend Family Practice
Family medicine · Jackson County
Priority review
CodingSpend
Codes level 4–5 office visits 2.26× as often as peers would for the same patient ages.$157,398
Oak Street Clinic
Family medicine · Greene County
Scheduled review
Coding
Appends modifier 25 (a separately billed procedure on the same day) 10.7× as often as peers.$110,753

Dollars by practice

The same paid dollars, divided different ways. A practice that leads on the raw total and falls away per patient is large; one that leads per patient is worth a look.

How it is computedDollars paid to the practice ÷ distinct patients it billed for, 2026Q3.

Across the selection: half of practices are at or below $332, and nine in ten are at or below $2,322.

  1. Caring Hands Home Care$9,674
  2. Hearthside Home Services$2,392
  3. Daily Living Supports$2,380
  4. Golden Years Aides$2,332
  5. HomeFirst Personal Care$2,324
  6. Trusted Companions$2,302
  7. Kindred Spirit Home Care$2,235
  8. Comfort Keepers of the Valley$2,192
  9. Motion Physical Therapy$2,010
  10. Clearwater Counseling$998
  11. New Path Behavioral$956
  12. Restore PT$560
  13. Bridgeway Therapy$550
  14. Stride Physical Therapy$545
  15. Balance Point Therapy$543
  16. Frontier Rehab$520
  17. Peak Rehab$508
  18. Kinetic Rehab Center$504
  19. Core Motion Rehab$502
  20. ActiveCare PT$502
  21. Greenleaf Therapy$338
  22. Stillwater Wellness$327
  23. Haven Counseling Center$326
  24. Compass Counseling$326
  25. Lighthouse Therapy$324

Checked, not flagged

Practices that resemble a pattern and were left alone, with the reason. A reviewer should be able to see what the analysis declined to raise.

  • Hearthside Home Services
    In-home personal care · Butler County
    • Paid per patient: not flagged — the only in-home personal care in Butler County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
    • Paid per visit: not flagged — the only in-home personal care in Butler County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
  • Golden Years Aides
    In-home personal care · Jasper County
    • Paid per patient: not flagged — the only in-home personal care in Jasper County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
    • Paid per visit: not flagged — the only in-home personal care in Jasper County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
  • Stride Physical Therapy
    Physical therapy · Jasper County
    • Paid per patient: not flagged — the only physical therapy in Jasper County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
    • Paid per visit: not flagged — the only physical therapy in Jasper County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
  • Prairie Health Partners
    Family medicine · Boone County
    • Growth comes from more patients (1.8×) at normal intensity — a practice still building its panel. Not flagged.
  • Frontier Rehab
    Physical therapy · Shannon County
    • Paid per patient: not flagged — the only physical therapy in Shannon County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
    • Paid per visit: not flagged — the only physical therapy in Shannon County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
  • Core Motion Rehab
    Physical therapy · Butler County
    • Paid per patient: not flagged — the only physical therapy in Butler County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
    • Paid per visit: not flagged — the only physical therapy in Butler County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
  • Bridgeway Therapy
    Mental health counseling · Boone County
    • Paid per patient: elevated this quarter only — persistence needs 2 of the last 3 quarters.

Unusually low

Low billing is a data-quality or access question (incomplete claims, under-service, a closed office) and is never routed to investigation.

No practice in this selection is unusually low this quarter.

How this is computed

  • No extract date was supplied, so every quarter is treated as complete. With one, quarters still inside their 90-day maturity window are held back.
  • Peers are the same specialty statewide; each practice is left out of its own reference.
  • Counts are shrunk toward the peer group (empirical Bayes) — a small practice needs more evidence to stand out.
  • A metric counts only if it exceeds 1.5× peers with 95% posterior probability, survives a 5% false-discovery control, and persists 2 of the last 3 quarters.
  • Practices under 30 visits or 11 patients a quarter are not compared.
  • E/M levels are age-standardised: an older panel is expected to code higher.
  • The only provider of a specialty in a county is not flagged on spend — high per-patient spend there can reflect access.
  • Growth from more patients at normal intensity is labelled expansion and never flagged.
  • Unusually LOW results go to a separate data-quality / access list, never to investigation.
  • Correlated signals are not added: each family counts once, by its strongest member.

Empirical-Bayes Gamma-Poisson against a leave-one-out peer reference; Benjamini-Hochberg across all metrics and specialties in the quarter; spend on a robust log-ratio scale; growth = patients × visits per patient × codes per visit × paid per code, compared with peer growth and county eligible growth.

Every number on this screen comes from run RUN-e13e368456792cc8, computed 2026-11-16 by engine billing-pattern-5 on input 0004c6ed954b… with parameters be6f8bfe67db…. The same input, engine and parameters always give this run.