Billing Pattern Watch
Paid claim lines compared with same-specialty peers: codes per visit, units, office-visit levels, modifiers, spend per patient and growth. A flag is a statistical anomaly for analyst review under 42 CFR 455.13–.14. It is not a finding of improper payment, and never a conclusion about intent.
Where each practice sits against its peers
Choose a measure. Select a mark to open the practice.
Each mark is a practice in the latest quarter. The funnel narrows as volume grows, so a small practice needs a larger ratio to sit outside it. Limits allow for overdispersion (φ = 1.0). The tier reflects every measure, persistence and the false-discovery control, not this chart alone.
Review list
Ordered by tier, then by the number of independent signal families, then by paid amount. Correlated measures count once per family.
| Practice | Tier | Signals | Leading observation | Paid in window |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Caring Hands Home Care In-home personal care · Jackson County | Priority review | SpendCodingBilled time | Paid per patient is 4.16× the peer median ($9,674 vs $2,324). | $1,037,160 |
| Motion Physical Therapy Physical therapy · Jackson County | Priority review | CodingSpendBilled time | Bills 2.39× the codes per visit of peers in the same specialty. | $424,015 |
| Clearwater Counseling Mental health counseling · Jackson County | Priority review | CodingVisitsSpend | Bills 1.72× the codes per visit of peers in the same specialty. | $236,432 |
| New Path Behavioral Mental health counseling · Greene County | Priority review | VisitsSpendGrowth | Sees each patient 2.96× as often as peers in the same specialty. | $180,570 |
| Riverbend Family Practice Family medicine · Jackson County | Priority review | CodingSpend | Codes level 4–5 office visits 2.26× as often as peers would for the same patient ages. | $157,398 |
| Oak Street Clinic Family medicine · Greene County | Scheduled review | Coding | Appends modifier 25 (a separately billed procedure on the same day) 10.7× as often as peers. | $110,753 |
Dollars by practice
The same paid dollars, divided different ways. A practice that leads on the raw total and falls away per patient is large; one that leads per patient is worth a look.
How it is computedDollars paid per patient ÷ the median paid per patient among same-specialty peers, this practice left out, 2026Q3.
Across the selection: half of practices are at or below 1.00×, and nine in ten are at or below 1.67×.
- Caring Hands Home Care4.16×
- Motion Physical Therapy3.91×
- Clearwater Counseling3.06×
- New Path Behavioral2.93×
- Bridgeway Therapy1.69×
- Riverbend Family Practice1.50×
- Oak Street Clinic1.31×
- Northside Family Care1.16×
- Restore PT1.09×
- Stride Physical Therapy1.06×
- Balance Point Therapy1.06×
- Greenleaf Therapy1.04×
- Hearthside Home Services1.03×
- Daily Living Supports1.02×
- Summit Family Medicine1.02×
- Westgate Health1.02×
- Pine Hollow Family Practice1.01×
- Meadowbrook Clinic1.00×
- Golden Years Aides1.00×
- Stillwater Wellness1.00×
- Haven Counseling Center1.00×
- Compass Counseling1.00×
- HomeFirst Personal Care1.00×
- Cedar Grove Primary Care1.00×
- Lighthouse Therapy0.99×
Checked, not flagged
Practices that resemble a pattern and were left alone, with the reason. A reviewer should be able to see what the analysis declined to raise.
- Hearthside Home ServicesIn-home personal care · Butler County
- Paid per patient: not flagged — the only in-home personal care in Butler County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
- Paid per visit: not flagged — the only in-home personal care in Butler County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
- Golden Years AidesIn-home personal care · Jasper County
- Paid per patient: not flagged — the only in-home personal care in Jasper County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
- Paid per visit: not flagged — the only in-home personal care in Jasper County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
- Stride Physical TherapyPhysical therapy · Jasper County
- Paid per patient: not flagged — the only physical therapy in Jasper County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
- Paid per visit: not flagged — the only physical therapy in Jasper County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
- Prairie Health PartnersFamily medicine · Boone County
- Growth comes from more patients (1.8×) at normal intensity — a practice still building its panel. Not flagged.
- Frontier RehabPhysical therapy · Shannon County
- Paid per patient: not flagged — the only physical therapy in Shannon County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
- Paid per visit: not flagged — the only physical therapy in Shannon County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
- Core Motion RehabPhysical therapy · Butler County
- Paid per patient: not flagged — the only physical therapy in Butler County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
- Paid per visit: not flagged — the only physical therapy in Butler County; high per-patient spend there can reflect access, not billing.
- Bridgeway TherapyMental health counseling · Boone County
- Paid per patient: elevated this quarter only — persistence needs 2 of the last 3 quarters.
Unusually low
Low billing is a data-quality or access question (incomplete claims, under-service, a closed office) and is never routed to investigation.
No practice in this selection is unusually low this quarter.
How this is computed
- No extract date was supplied, so every quarter is treated as complete. With one, quarters still inside their 90-day maturity window are held back.
- Peers are the same specialty statewide; each practice is left out of its own reference.
- Counts are shrunk toward the peer group (empirical Bayes) — a small practice needs more evidence to stand out.
- A metric counts only if it exceeds 1.5× peers with 95% posterior probability, survives a 5% false-discovery control, and persists 2 of the last 3 quarters.
- Practices under 30 visits or 11 patients a quarter are not compared.
- E/M levels are age-standardised: an older panel is expected to code higher.
- The only provider of a specialty in a county is not flagged on spend — high per-patient spend there can reflect access.
- Growth from more patients at normal intensity is labelled expansion and never flagged.
- Unusually LOW results go to a separate data-quality / access list, never to investigation.
- Correlated signals are not added: each family counts once, by its strongest member.
Empirical-Bayes Gamma-Poisson against a leave-one-out peer reference; Benjamini-Hochberg across all metrics and specialties in the quarter; spend on a robust log-ratio scale; growth = patients × visits per patient × codes per visit × paid per code, compared with peer growth and county eligible growth.
Every number on this screen comes from run RUN-e13e368456792cc8, computed 2026-11-16 by engine billing-pattern-5 on input 0004c6ed954b… with parameters be6f8bfe67db…. The same input, engine and parameters always give this run.