VARDR Program Review
Missouri

Synthetic data. Practice names are invented. Several practices carry planted billing patterns, and several benign look-alikes are planted to show what the analysis declines to flag. Cases, people and outcomes are invented too.

← PI-MO-20260915-001

Synthetic demonstration record · not a real referral

Referral of suspected provider misconduct

To
Medicaid Fraud Control Unit
Office of the Attorney General
From
Missouri Department of Social Services, Missouri Medicaid Audit & Compliance (MMAC)
Agency case
PI-MO-20260915-001
Package
Version 1, built 2026-09-23

Basis for this referral

  • 42 CFR 455.21(a)(1): Refer all cases of suspected provider fraud to the MFCU.
  • RSMo 191.910.4: Listed reports "shall be referred to the attorney general".
  • Contents follow the CMS-MIG Performance Standard for Referrals of Suspected Fraud (2008).
  • Disclosure: 42 CFR 431.302(d); 45 CFR 164.512(d).

Required contents

1. Subject: name, Medicaid provider ID, address, provider type
Caring Hands Home Care; Medicaid provider ID / NPI 9102693238; In-home personal care; Jackson County
2. Source or origin of the complaint
Agency claims-data analysis (Vardr billing-pattern review, batch synthetic-MO), followed by agency preliminary and full investigation.
3. Date reported to the State
2026-09-15
4. Description of suspected misconduct: category of service, factual explanation, Medicaid statutes/rules/policies potentially violated, dates of conduct
Category of service: In-home personal care. Factual explanation: Personal care units were paid for aide-days on which visit verification records show no visit, and for which the provider could not supply timesheets. Dates of conduct: 2026-04-01 to 2026-09-30.
5. Amount paid to the provider for the past 3 years or the period of the alleged misconduct, whichever is greater
Not available. Paid in the analysis window (2025Q2–2026Q3): $1,037,160. The 3-year figure the standard asks for must come from the MMIS paid-claims history; the analysis extract covers 2025Q2–2026Q3 only.
6. All communications between the State and the provider about the conduct at issue
2026-09-21 — Records request and response: The agency requested timesheets for the sampled days. The provider supplied timesheets for 11 of the 40.
7. Contact for a State staff member with practical knowledge of the program
Riley Santangelo, Investigator, Program Integrity; 573-555-0142; program.integrity@example.gov
8. Sample or exposed dollar amount, when available
Not available. Not estimated. A statistical difference from peers is not an exposed dollar amount; exposure requires a sample or record review the MFCU may direct.

Supporting detail

1. NPI and license number
NPI 9102693238; license number: from the enrollment file.
2. Date and method of detection; investigative steps taken
2026-09-15: statistical review of paid claims against same-specialty peers. Paid per patient is 4.16× the peer median ($9,674 vs $2,324). Bills 4.09× the units per code line peers bill for the same codes. 394 clinician-days in the last two quarters with more than 16 hours of timed services billed for one clinician (3 clinicians; peak 84 h in a day).
3. Supporting documents: claims, medical records, correspondence
Line-level review of T1019, 2026Q2–Q3 (claims review) Visit verification records for a sample of 40 aide-days (medical records) Records request and response (provider communication)
4. Other agencies notified; corrective actions already taken
Not available. No other agency notified; no administrative action taken.

Laws, rules or policies potentially implicated

None selected. The State rule pack is pending agency counsel; the unit may identify the applicable provisions.

Deliberately not included

  • Federal tax information (IRC 6103(l)(7) / IEVS) — not shared with an MFCU unless separately authorized (42 CFR 431.300(c)(1)).
  • Substance-use-disorder records under 42 CFR Part 2 — excluded unless counsel clears a specific basis.

Review of this version

  • Agency counsel: approved, Priya Raman, 2026-09-24. Elements complete. Citations left for the unit.
  • Director: approved, Elena Whitcombe, 2026-09-25

Counsel and the director have both approved this version. Transmitted 2026-09-26.

This referral reports facts and the provisions they may bear on. It makes no finding of fraud or of intent; those are for the unit and the courts.

Package sha256 b9de0fabfa3cdef25e783448b8092f4cd48f9884b5bae2f3c2ad2e8b8ee45515